Ceri has been talking about submitting short fiction to magazines, and I’ve been talking about pitching this non-fic anthology series to my publisher, and I’ve only just had the realisation dawn upon me.
If this goes through, I’ll be the one sending rejection letters.
Ouch.
Also on the subject of selecting stories: I’ve been having trouble nailing down the specific selection criteria in this proposal. Stories must feel sincere; check. Stories must involve original, out-of-the-ordinary situations; check. Stories must have appeal; check. Stories must be in sympathy with the theme of the anthology in question; check. My publisher wants me to expand upon the criteria I already have.
Other than that, what do I say? How am I going to choose the stories? Honestly, writing down that I’m basically going to be using the Force and trusting my intuition in the process of story selection and approval is going to get me and my proposal laughed out of the office.
So help me out, dear readers. When you read an anthology, and one story or chapter sticks out (for positive or negative reasons), can you describe why? How do you put that je ne sais quoi into words? What makes a certain piece of writing special, and the others flat? Why does one succeed, and others fail?